nomonkeybusiness.org

a no-nonsense clearing in
the personal finance jungle

By whom

Stuart Fowler - professional investor and finance author

For whom

Anyone trying to sort sense from nonsense in a seriously conflicted financial services industry

Business connections

Wealth Management

Wealth management & planning for individuals

Workshops

Workshops for individuals and employee groups

Book

No Monkey Business: what Investors need to know and why

(FT Prentice Hall 2002)

email Stuart Fowler

Thursday, May 26th

D(epolarisation) Day: what might have been For grown-up consumers


From 1st June all financial advisers must spell out whether they are independent agents or tied to one or more product manufacturers and what and how they get paid. It's the last step in the FSA's 'depolarisation' programme and a much watered down version of its original plan to make the adviser/salesman distinction clearer and prevent commission bias. How watered down is demonstrated by the belief in the industry it need make no effective difference to how you run your business. Fee options, instead of commissions, will become more widespread but hardly any consumers will be able to work out from the charges 'menu' how much commissions will really cost them over the long term, or what other contingent costs they will have to pay by choosing commissions instead of the fee option.

Compare this with what happened in the USA in the 1980s, when a very public feud developed between fee and commission firms. Fee-charging firms were able to differentiate themselves clearly from commission-driven salesmen. By staking out the moral high ground, 'professional' advisers ended up with the largest market share. Breaking the hold that commissions give product manufacturers over distributors led to lower product costs and higher financial planning standards. It could have been so different here on 1st June - poles apart, even.

Stuart Fowler on 05.26.05 @ 06:53 PM GMT [">link]


Monday, May 23rd

Affordable mortgages for key workers For grown-up consumers


Stability Brown has come up with a new tweak for a market that's misbehaving. It seems that in 9 out of 10 major cities key public sector workers can't afford to buy homes. His big idea is to encourage lenders to provide shared mortgages with the Government (us, actually) underwriting part of the equity risk. With house prices about 50% above their sustainable level in real terms, the problem is not limited to public sector workers and is the result of an unsustainable credit binge - one of several indicators that the stability Brown boasts about is masking deep cyclical problems. Buyers have a simple remedy when an asset is not easily affordable, particularly when they can see it is equally unaffordable for millions like them: go on strike. Rent not buy.
There should be a second alternative. When people could not afford a freehold, they used to buy a lease - which is a fraction of a freehold. Why should people on modest incomes be forced in an inefficient market to buy an asset which will outlive their own lifetime needs? That's not a property-owning democracy: it's enforced penury. An efficient property market needs regulations friendly to both the supply side and the demand side and it needs them in both the rental and leasehold market. But that's another story.
Stuart Fowler on 05.23.05 @ 10:13 AM GMT [">link]


Friday, May 6th

The cost wedge just got fatter For grown-up consumers



Most personal finance sections have recently converged on the story that several large fund management houses are pushing up annual management charges again. This is an inevitable consequence of consumers using more agents, including the internet, to avoid or cut front-end loaded sales commissions. The effect is that more of the commission payments from providers to distributors must take the form of a share of the annual management charge, making distribution costs more equal across different types of fund and the 'cost wedge' harder to avoid. It is also an unintended (but predictable) consequence of the Treasury validating 1.5% as the cost ceiling for stakeholder products, as this encourages consumers to view a relatively high point in the cost wedge as its thin end.

The only way consumers can avoid the wedge, and the biases it creates in financial advice, is to pay for advice by fee, not commissions. If people understood what commissions cost them personally and what they do collectively to the product of the nations' savings, this mad, mad world would be turned upside down. Read on and you will see how you can turn it around for yourself. If you are currently placed at the average level of the wedge, you can generate up to a third more money in 20 years by working your way back down it.

Stuart Fowler on 05.06.05 @ 10:11 AM GMT [">more..]


Monday, May 2nd

Equity risk and time For professionals



Talking Head, FTfm, 2nd May. The relationship between equity risk and time is a key battle ground in the conflict between ‘fair value’ accountants, for whom equity investing is a huge gamble by people who ‘should know better’, and investment professionals and many actuaries, who are more trustful of the benefits of equity investing, for most individuals and the nation state collectively. FTfm has been reporting one particular confrontation, between John Ralfe, a champion of fair value accountants, and Adair Turner who, though not a professional, relied in his Pensions Commission report on a popular claim made by professionals that equities are less risky for a long-term investor. As typically presented, this claim is indeed the howler Ralfe suggested. Yet it does not need much rephrasing to turn Turner’s intuition into wise counsel.

Stuart Fowler on 05.02.05 @ 03:57 PM GMT [">more..]




Home
Archives

Topical Index:

Items are colour-coded:
For Kids Kids’ stuff
For Consumers For grown-up consumers
For Professionals Mainly for professionals
Showing Off Showing off

Monkey tricks
With-profits
Endowments
Precipice bonds
Commissions
Cost wedge

Investment sense and nonsense
Active v tracking
Accountants v actuaries
Low risk products
Asset allocation
Money illusion
Property myths
Equity returns
Pensions
Alternative investments

Making monkeys of ourselves
Personal responsibility
Streetwise finance
Kids' stuff

Public policy sense and nonsense
Regulations
Competition policy

<>May 2005
SMTWTFS
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Powered By Greymatter

External Links:

FSA consumer help
Investors Association forum
FT Your Money portal
The Motley Fool
ABI pension calculator
Pension glossary
Index of economics blogs
House Price Crash blog