nomonkeybusiness.org

a no-nonsense clearing in
the personal finance jungle

By whom

Stuart Fowler - professional investor and finance author

For whom

Anyone trying to sort sense from nonsense in a seriously conflicted financial services industry

Business connections

Wealth Management

Wealth management & planning for individuals

Workshops

Workshops for individuals and employee groups

Book

No Monkey Business: what Investors need to know and why

(FT Prentice Hall 2002)

email Stuart Fowler

Friday, June 29th

The FSA validates fees for advice For grown-up consumers



The key proposals of the FSA Retail Distribution Review were well trailed - here as elsewhere. The main one is a gamble: forcing IFAs into a professional business model will also push it even further into the high end of consumer income and assets, leaving an even bigger mass-market gap below it to be filled by better products and service formats. It is a gamble because this mass market space has so far been dominated (and abysmally served) by underqualified transaction-orientated IFAs and banks. Both have the worst records managing the conflicts betwen sales incentives and treating customers as fellow humans.

I will return to the gamble in respect of these groups in a later post. My first comments are on the implication that consumers will be able to trust a freshly-branded 'profession' of independent financial planners just because of collective actions, such as fees agreed with the customer (instead of commissions agreed with providers), membership of trade associations and threshold exam qualifications. There are already many firms who rightly claim all of these in their marketing literature. As insiders, what we know is that these firms nonetheless offer wildly different value propositions. The differences that count are not so much in their traditional financial planning expertise but in their grasp of the core investment skills, and consequently in their thinking and processes, as well as a wide range of differences in clients' all-in costs. Customers need to discriminate rather than rely on labels, even a fresh set of labels.
Stuart Fowler on 06.29.07 @ 08:05 PM GMT [">more..]


Monday, June 18th

Valuing fees: coffee with a twist For grown-up consumers


Our observation in Anticipating the Retail Distribution Review that the business model for financial advice will not change unless and until customers learn the value of paying fees for a professional and independent service was echoed in an article in the Observer yesterday by Heather Connon. As well as quoting us, Heather quoted insurance-company analyst Ned Cazalet referring to ‘research showing that three out of four consumers say they would not pay for financial advice and even those happy to do so would baulk at a fee of more than £75’. Added Heather: ‘hardly enough to pay an adviser’s coffee bill’. Viewed differently, the full likely cost of commission bias for an investor contributing £5,000 pa in real terms every year for 40 years is an outcome reduced by £200,000 (also in real terms). That’s about £90,000 in present value terms. That pays for a lot of advice as well as a lot of coffee.

Stuart Fowler on 06.18.07 @ 12:58 PM GMT [">link]


Saturday, June 16th

Barclays Bank to take over trust-based financial planning - oh yes? For grown-up consumers


Barclays Bank has moved its tanks (a 900-strong regiment of ‘Financial Planning Managers’) onto the independent financial advisers’ lawn. Barclays’ National Sales Director has told an industry conference (PIMS) that it has the people, ‘sales training programme’, processes and ‘open-architecture’ products in place to dominate the IFAs’ high-net-worth client segment. Could this be the same Barclays Bank whose people and processes were secretly filmed by Channel 4, responding to deliberate management incentives to sell unwanted and poor-value services to anyone foolish enough to wander into a branch? See my post on the programme.

The fact the Barclays managers not only could not control their sales force but set up perverse incentives was hardly a shock but this was significant because they were caught in flagrante delicto. So what sort of rumpus ensued? None that I can see. This proves the point in our briefing on the FSA’s latest attempt to deal with commission bias in the UK (today’s earlier post): unless consumers vote with their feet, businesses will continue to take advantage of them.

Stuart Fowler on 06.16.07 @ 06:24 PM GMT [">link]


Friday, June 15th

Anticipating the Retail Distribution Review


The Discussion Paper resulting from the FSA review of the failed business model for long-term savings in the UK will be presented by the FSA at a conference on 27th June. No Monkey Business Limited circulated this briefing to financial journalists, anticipating what it will say. Our advice: don't expect any silver bullet - all the big initiatives tried by the FSA as all-powerful regulator have failed. This represents a more humble call to collective action by the industry, in other words market-based solutions underpinned by sound economics. By definition these have to be disruptive. The biggest risk for disruptive businesss models in the UK is that the better customer proposition will not be valued by consumers. Whatever this report says, this is a huge disincentive in the UK where indifferent consumers invite poor service, poor products, poor value and hugely diminished outcomes for their savings. Even in a marketplace where firms comply with FSA principles of fair treatment of customers, we will still get the business models we deserve.
admin on 06.15.07 @ 02:59 PM GMT [">link]




Home
Archives

Topical Index:

Items are colour-coded:
For Kids Kids’ stuff
For Consumers For grown-up consumers
For Professionals Mainly for professionals
Showing Off Showing off

Monkey tricks
With-profits
Endowments
Precipice bonds
Commissions
Cost wedge

Investment sense and nonsense
Active v tracking
Accountants v actuaries
Low risk products
Asset allocation
Money illusion
Property myths
Equity returns
Pensions
Alternative investments

Making monkeys of ourselves
Personal responsibility
Streetwise finance
Kids' stuff

Public policy sense and nonsense
Regulations
Competition policy

<>June 2007
SMTWTFS
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Powered By Greymatter

External Links:

FSA consumer help
Investors Association forum
FT Your Money portal
The Motley Fool
ABI pension calculator
Pension glossary
Index of economics blogs
House Price Crash blog